For so called Pentecostal churches it is characteristic that they
insist on signs and miracles by which believers try to prove that
they are with God. The simplest way to notice that in their case a
manifestation of miracle is not from God is the example of their gift
to speak in unintelligible tongues.
The real gift of speaking unintelligible tongues, together with other
gifts, was given to Christ's disciples on the Day of Pentecost when
they were all filled with Holy Spirit, so that they could preach the
Gospel more powerfully (Acts 2). The gift of tongues received
its practical application three and half years later when they
started
preaching the Gospel to pagans (in their mother tongues which
Christ's
disciples had not been familiar with).
The possession of spiritual gifts is not purpose for itself, but the
means of expressing love.
In his attempt to respond to the needs of the church and the world,
man notices that he lacks different gifts and that is why the Holy
Spirit gives those gifts to him as well as His divine power to apply
them.
Contrary to the real gift of tongue, the false gift of tongues does
not have the qualities of a spiritual gift (it does not serve for
preaching the Gospel) but has the qualities of a
"spiritual" fruit.
By means of his gender of impure gender, man imitates his feeling
of self-justice in him.
It appeared for the first time in history with the female oracles
in Delphi and then, not far away in the Corinthian church.
You can see that God's spirit has not been disclosed through the
above
mentioned manifestation of the gift in Corinth, by the fact that
apostle
Paul had to write an epistle to the Corinthians telling them how to
"self-control" that gift, as though the Holy Spirit, if
working
through
that gift, did not have the power to control itself and remind the
believers of the desperate situation the church was in.
Contrary to the real gift of tongue, the false gift does not demand
the unity of church (1 Corinthians 1:11-12; 11:18-19).
As it is not a spiritual gift, it does not serve people (1
Corinthians
14:2), but serves for abomination (1 Corinthians 14:23).
It develops one's own self-justice and not the church (1 Corinthians
14:4). It demands a translator (1 Corinthians 14:9).
It is mindless (1 Corinthians 14:14.20). As it is not the
fruit of God's spirit it has to control itself (1. Corinthians.
14:27-28)
and is characterized by disorder (1 Corinthians. 14:23.31-33).
If we ask the one who has been "baptized" by such a gift of
tongues,
about
the purpose of that gift, what kind of blessings and advantages he
has
considering that he cannot understand it with his
mind, we shall notice that the person will not be able to provide
a sensible and rational answer to us. He will explain to us that the
Holy Spirit is praying through him in his own divine tongue without
justifying its practical importance for him. It represents the
temptation for man's sinful and self-righteous nature which
would first accept anything else rather than salvation, than Christ.
When we ask a religious supporter of meditation why he needs to
meditate
when there is already God to pray to, he will try to convince us that
meditation helps him in the spiritual development and will list the
same arguments the bearers of the gift of tongue use in order to
justify
their speaking in unintelligible tongues. The one who really
believes in God, naturally does not need any additional technique.
If the Spirit has a message for someone, He will then forward it by
the gift of
prophecy on the language understandable to that
person.
Accordingly, it is absurd to reveal the Spirit by means of gift in
the tongue not familiar to the bearer of that particular gift. Does
not the Holy Spirit have the power to pray in the language
understandable
to any man?! Is not the revelation of the Creator in the world
created
adapted to His creatures?
It is impossible for us to love God with our soul and all our mind
if our mind does not take part in expressing that love, but only is
a passive and useless audience.
And if a bearer of the gift of tongue "must" pray in an
unintelligible
tongue which meaning is hidden, why is it necessary for him to be
aware of the
prayer of the Holy Spirit when he does not understand it? Why should
my mind listen to the things that do not bring any fruit to it? There
are many important happenings but they will burden our mind only if
we are aware of them.
It would be the same thing if I put a microphone in front of my mouth
during a meal in order to be able to amplify the sound of my slurping
and thus increase my own enjoyment in food. Chewing is important and
necessary but it does not mean that I must listen to it.
It is even more unreasonable for a man to subdue to the spirit
without
the participation of his mind and a voluntary choice of God through
the
understanding
and acceptance of his character (and that is also close to the
experience
of meditation).
Sometimes, those who have the "gift of tongue" say:
"Try the
experience
of the gift of tongue and you will see how good it feels." Thus
they lead man to check the offered way by personal experience, in
the same way by which Satan had tempted Eve. However, experience
is not a criterion (Genesis 3:6). Faith, contrary to an
assumption, must have reasonable foundations. Man is responsible to
examine the inspiration of spiritual experience intellectually and
not to "gamble" with himself/herself by means of senseless
subduing
of his will to the power which obsesses him. That is why apostle Paul
reminds the Corinthians:
"For if I pray in an unknown tongue, my spirit prayeth, but my
understanding
is unfruitful. What is it then? I will pray with the spirit, and I
will pray with the understanding also: I will sing with the spirit,
and I will sing with the understanding also. ... Brethren, be not
children in understanding: howbeit in malice be ye children, but in
understanding be men." (1 Corinthians 14:21)
A false gift simply does not have any other purpose but to give to
a sinner a "proof" of God's acceptance and calm down his
impure
conscience.
Among their supporters one can observe the fruit of that subtle form
of justification by works. We shall hear conversation
like the following: "And have you been baptized by the Holy
Spirit?...
Lucky you! I haven't been baptized by it yet but I hardly wait to
start
to speak in tongues myself!"
The plan of salvation is sufficient and complete so that there is
no need for its further compensation and improvement by means of some
additions as such as could be, for example, the above mentioned gift
of tongue.
Contrary to the false gift of tongue which scandalizes the unfaithful
(1 Corinthians 14:23), the real gift of tongue actually
represents a sign to the unfaithful (1 Corinthians 14:22).
Being a gift, it serves to import others (1 Corinthians 14:12.19.26).
It is characterized by the spiritual unity of the church (Acts
2:1). It does not need a translator (Acts 2:6-8).
It is reasonable (1 Corinthians 14:15). It does not have
to self-control itself as it inspired by God (Acts 2:4).
It is characterized by decency and order (1 Corinthians. 14:40).
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |